A history lesson

Broadcaster gets apology from BBC as history repeats itself

Here's a news item which is quite amusing to read since it is obvious that only a junior researcher would make such a fundamental mistake as to plagiarise whole sections of an established documentary, but there are two important lessons that the BBC ought to have learnt from the whole incident and other broadcasters should treat this incident seriously instead of simply taking delight in the BBC's discomfort.

Firstly, the BBC documentary was billed as being "Written and presented by Dan Cruickshank" whereas it transpired that it turned out to be not entirely the case - how much of a documentary has to be physically written by someone before a programme maker can claim that it was "written" by them? As a viewer, when I see someone like Dan Cruickshank present a programme I expect that person to have done at least some of the basic research since they appear to be the 'authority' on the subject.

Secondly, and perhaps the most important point to be drawn from the whole incident is that it is very difficult to produce good factual programming on a budget, and the BBC's recent cutbacks in research staff appear to be even more badly judged in the light of this incident, even if they are totally unrelated.

Sorry. Comments have been disabled on this post.

MediaBlog

MediaBlog

Feeds

This Article

Email Newsletter

Get all our updates in your inbox - every time there's news to tell. Just enter your email address and select "Subscribe". Or if you no longer want to receive our mailings, enter your email and select "Unsubscribe"

Small Print

Opinions expressed in these posts are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Transdiffusion Broadcasting System in general.

These posts and their multimedia are copyright. Some rights are reserved under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence.

The Index

From Twitter

RT @spikester: watching an episode of Horizon from 1989. no unnecessary music, no stupid reconstructions, long interviews from a static ...

Posted on 20 May at 21:19

RT @TBS_News: New on YouTube: RTBF1 startup 1990 http://t.co/XmpUP5bS

Posted on 20 May at 17:36

RT @TBS_News: New on YouTube: Nederland 1 opticals http://t.co/KCK1HCoA

Posted on 20 May at 17:36

Follow us on Twitter ⇒

Archiving Project

Find out more about our new archiving project and how you can help from the comfort of your own computer

Read more and join in ⇒

Transdiffusion Navigation

May 2012

Transdiffusion Broadcasting System

This web page lives at: http://www.transdiffusion.org/blog/2004/05/a_history_lesson